How to Cook Polenta: Soft, Set and Braaied
Polenta is coarsely ground yellow maize meal, and if you grew up on pap you already know more about it than you think. Cooked soft, it is creamy and comforting, like a richer, butterier stywe pap. Cooked firmer and left to set, it can be sliced and grilled on the braai, fried, or baked into crisp chips. It is naturally gluten-free and very forgiving once you know the basic ratios.
Polenta vs pap
Both are made from ground maize. South African maize meal is usually white and finer, while polenta is typically made from yellow maize and has a coarser grind, giving a sweeter flavour and more texture. Italian cooks enrich it with butter and cheese; South African cooks will recognise the method immediately. Polenta goes very well with braaied meat, tomato relish and chakalaka.
The ratios
- Soft, spoonable polenta: 1 part polenta to 4–5 parts liquid by volume. For four people, use 1 cup (about 170 g) polenta to 1 litre of liquid.
- Firm polenta for setting: 1 part polenta to 3½–4 parts liquid. For a 20 x 30 cm tray, use 1½ cups (about 250 g) polenta to 1.25 litres of liquid.
The liquid can be water, stock, milk or a mix. Stock gives a savoury flavour; a little milk makes it creamier.
How to cook soft polenta
- Bring 1 litre of water or stock to the boil in a heavy-based pot. Add 5 ml salt.
- Reduce the heat to medium. Pour in the polenta in a slow, steady stream while whisking constantly to prevent lumps.
- Once it thickens, switch to a wooden spoon and turn the heat to low. It will bubble and spit, so a lid placed slightly ajar helps.
- Cook, stirring every few minutes and scraping the bottom, until thick and the grains are soft:
- Traditional coarse polenta: 30–45 minutes
- Quick-cook or fine polenta: 5–10 minutes (check the pack)
- Stir in 30–45 ml butter and, if you like, a handful of grated parmesan or cheddar. Season with black pepper.
- Serve immediately. Soft polenta thickens as it cools; loosen it with a splash of hot water or milk.
How to make set polenta for the braai
- Cook firm polenta as above using the firmer ratio, until very thick and pulling away from the sides of the pot.
- Stir in butter, cheese and herbs – 15 ml chopped fresh rosemary or 10 ml dried mixed herbs works well.
- Pour into an oiled 20 x 30 cm tray and smooth the top to about 2 cm thick.
- Cool, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours, or overnight, until completely firm.
- Turn out and cut into slabs or wedges.
Grilling on the braai
Brush the slices generously with olive oil. Grill over medium coals on a clean, well-oiled grid for 4–5 minutes per side without moving them, until marked and crisp. Turning too early will make them stick. A hinged grid makes this much easier.
Polenta chips
Cut set polenta into chunky chips. Toss in olive oil, salt, 5 ml garlic powder and 5 ml smoked paprika. Spread on a lined tray and bake at 220°C for 25–30 minutes, turning once, until golden and crunchy. An air fryer at 200°C takes about 15 minutes.
Seasoning ideas
- Cheese and herbs: parmesan, thyme and black pepper
- Braai-style: stir a spoonful of your favourite spice rub into set polenta – our homemade braai spice rubs work well
- Breakfast: cook soft polenta with half milk, then top with honey and cinnamon or a fried egg
Common problems
- Lumpy: the polenta went in too quickly. Whisk hard, or blitz briefly with a stick blender.
- Gritty: it needs longer cooking. Add a little more liquid and keep going.
- Bland: polenta needs generous salt, about 5–7.5 ml per litre of water, plus butter or cheese at the end.
Storage
Keep uncooked polenta in an airtight container in a cool, dry cupboard and use it within six to nine months. Set polenta keeps covered in the fridge for up to five days, so you can make a tray ahead of a weekend braai.
Find polenta, flours and grains in our Beans, Legumes, Grains, Veg and Flours collection.