Small dark mustard-type seeds in a glass jar on a white table

Black vs Yellow Mustard Seeds: How to Use Them

Mustard seeds are one of the most useful and least understood spices in the cupboard. The same small seed can give you the nutty crackle of a Durban curry tempering, the sharp heat of English mustard or the gentle bite of a pickling brine. The difference comes down to which seed you use and how you treat it.

Black vs yellow mustard seeds

Black mustard seeds, which range from dark brown to almost black, are smaller and more pungent. They are the seed of choice in Indian cooking, where they are fried in hot oil until they pop, losing their raw bite and turning nutty and savoury.

Yellow mustard seeds, sometimes called white mustard, are larger, paler and milder. They are the main seed in American-style yellow mustard and most pickling spice mixes, and they hold their shape well in brines.

Why mustard heat changes

Whole mustard seeds are not hot on their own. The heat develops when the seed is crushed and mixed with cold liquid, which triggers a natural reaction that creates the sharp, nose-tingling flavour. A few practical rules follow from this:

  • Cold water gives the strongest heat; hot water and acids such as vinegar produce a milder, more stable mustard.
  • Let mixed mustard powder stand for about 10 minutes before adding vinegar or salt so the heat can fully develop.
  • Frying whole seeds in oil, or cooking them for a long time, tames the heat and brings out a nutty flavour instead.

How to temper mustard seeds (tadka)

Tempering is the base of countless Indian and Durban dishes: dhal, vegetable curries, sambals, rice and atchar. Here is the method:

  1. Heat 1–2 tablespoons oil or ghee in a small pan over medium-high heat.
  2. Add 1 teaspoon black mustard seeds. Have a lid ready.
  3. Within 20–40 seconds they will start to pop. Partly cover the pan and let most of them crackle.
  4. Add ½ teaspoon cumin seeds, a sprig of curry leaves and a pinch of turmeric. Stir for 10 seconds.
  5. Pour the sizzling oil over cooked dhal, or use it as the base of your curry before adding onions.

The seeds should pop, not burn. If they turn grey and smell acrid, start again, because burnt seeds make the whole dish bitter.

Homemade wholegrain mustard

Making your own mustard takes ten minutes of work and a little patience. This makes about one 250 ml jar.

  • 3 tablespoons yellow mustard seeds
  • 2 tablespoons black mustard seeds
  • 80 ml apple cider or white wine vinegar
  • 60 ml water
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1–2 teaspoons honey (optional)
  1. Combine the seeds, vinegar and water in a clean glass jar. Cover and leave at room temperature for 24–48 hours, until the seeds have absorbed most of the liquid.
  2. Add the salt and honey. Blend briefly with a stick blender, leaving plenty of whole seeds. Add a splash of water if it is too thick.
  3. Seal and refrigerate. It is very sharp at first and mellows over the next week or two. It keeps for at least a month in the fridge.

Serve it with braaied boerewors, cold Christmas gammon or a cheese board, or whisk a teaspoon into a salad dressing.

Other ways to use mustard seeds

  • Pickles and atchar: yellow seeds go into pickling brines for cucumbers, onions and beetroot, while black seeds and fenugreek seeds are classic in mango atchar. Our pickling seeds blend is a handy shortcut.
  • Pickled fish: a teaspoon of yellow seeds in the vinegar sauce adds texture to Cape Malay pickled fish.
  • Braai marinades: mustard powder helps bind oil and vinegar together and adds a gentle kick to marinades for chicken and pork.
  • Potato salad and coleslaw: fry a teaspoon of black seeds in oil and toss through warm potatoes with spring onion.

Storage

Whole mustard seeds are very stable and keep their quality for two to three years in an airtight jar away from heat and light. Mustard powder loses pungency faster, so aim to use it within a year.

Pair them with dried curry leaves for an authentic tempering, and find both seeds in our Spices, Herbs and Seeds collection.

Back to blog